20 replies to this topic

[boris4ka]

My friend challenged me on another website, but he's staff there and people like him, and I only have 6 posts, so I think I'm not getting a fair vote. So what do you people think of these sigs?

Mine:



OR

His:



Thx for voting!

[MindBender]

I vote HIs......

Edited by MindBender, 27 May 2006 - 08:16 PM.

[Tacoman]

without the car and the text, yours, but how is,
his

[Muck13]

u need to fix the text and remove the care and i think itll b fine but i dont like ur friends sig either but i would vote for him.

[zBlade]

His.

[Just Dave]

Hmm... Boris, it's 4 to 0... I won again.

And also, you guys would take a brushed background with practically nothing to it instead of my sig? Wow... reality check, maybe?

-Peace

[Guided]

I'm sorry but DL'd brushes and crappy typo vs. C4D's filters and defaults (and possibly pen tool).. There is no skill in DL'd brushes you give a complete newbie to photoshop some downloaded brushes and say make something then they can make something like that. Whereas if you give a complete newbie C4D's and tell them where the filters are they will make nothing as good as Daves.

Dave gmv.

Ok Boris. Cut down the tag size (heightxwidth) take away the car render change the font. And just try new styles. Get off DL'd brushes. Where yes, brushes can be used to a good extent - They're just a lower GFX skill style.

[ecker00]

I like his and agree Guided

[Dirk Black]

not to beat a dead horse but I would go with his, dont you see how much cleaner and simpler it is? Yours is cool looking, it just doesnt communicate anything other than wild lines and a CAR.. keep it up though

[Just Dave]

Thank you.

[ecker00]

hehe, have a feeling that Just Dave is "His"

np man ^^

Edit: aah lol, the sig even say "JD" wohoo xP

Edited by ecker00, 29 May 2006 - 12:02 PM.

[MindBender]

So, the outcome is like I told Boris we dont vote for the people we vote the sig at our site thank you P2L .....

[Neg]

They could both use some work, but I like yours best. Yours is too tall, in my opinion.

Edited by Neg, 08 June 2006 - 12:02 AM.

[Donna]

Neg, on Jun 8 2006, 03:55 PM, said:

I think that his sucks and yours is too tall.

I think you need to read this: http://www.pixel2lif...?showtopic=8683

[Love]

Yours isn't loading for me. :/

[daulex]

don't see the first one

[dinges]

what they said
picture isn't working anymore

[d2Squared]

i really like urs....
but the car just doesnt look like its in place, u shold move it more to the side and lower the opacity or something.
about "His", its too simple for me, and i dont like very simple, in my opinion it need more things in it, just an opinion.
well, i guess i made my point...

good luck with more challanges

[M2B]

Comments removed by Donna

Off you go and read http://www.pixel2lif...?showtopic=8683 again

Edited by Donna, 12 June 2006 - 12:20 AM.

[syntex]

I personally think the first one is messd up,
The 2nd one appeals to me much more!!