Not Fully finished products.

First design seems just like most designs already out there. As for the 2nd Design. If it's a phone and you don't have a touch pad I'm guessing it's a touch screen so technically you don't need that center scroll well thing you have. Just doesn't make sense. Other buttons are alright but the wheel thing just defeats the purpose of having a touch screen.

I'm sorry if I seem so negative but I just say it how it is. It's the only way an artist can grow. It's a nice try at it though and probably a lot better then what I could do in photoshop since I only use it to texture my 3D models.

I suggest you try a couple more but try new designs and really think about the practicality of it. Don't just look at other phones but look in your mind and see what you would really like a phone to be like. Or else you'll always be following others instead of leading the way in designs.

there is never no negative comments, only criticism to improve so thank you!

I like the minimal and simple things. So the 1st version is better for me. And thats true, there is no need central button when it have touch-screen.